Medicinal mushrooms and psychedelic mushrooms, the difference explained

The difference between Psychedelic & medicinal Mushrooms

Posted by Sharon Fernie on

The mushroom kingdom is huge. There are poisonous mushrooms, psychedelic mushrooms, and also edible and medicinal mushrooms. As more and more people discover the fascinating world of fungi, I often notice confusion about the difference between them. So in this article I would love to clear things up: what medicinal mushrooms are, what psychedelic mushrooms are, and why they are two very different worlds.

My name is Sharon Fernie and I am the founder of Herbal Cacao, where we share high-quality ceremonial cacao blends with herbs, spices and mushrooms. I have a deep passion for holistic wellness and ancient traditions, and through Herbal Cacao our mission is to support our community on their journey of self-discovery and spiritual growth. Because we work with functional mushrooms in our blends, this is a question I am asked often, and one I love to answer with clarity.

Here in the Herbal Cacao Journal, I explore medicinal mushrooms, sacred plants and the research behind them, often woven together with experiences from my own life. So whether you are new to the world of fungi or already enjoy mushrooms in your cacao, this is your invitation to understand the difference and choose with confidence.

Begin your guided cacao ritual with Herbal Cacao

Medicinal mushrooms, also called functional mushrooms, are not psychoactive. They have been part of traditional Eastern medicine for thousands of years and are now gaining attention in the West.

Medicinal mushrooms

For thousands of years, medicinal mushrooms, or functional mushrooms, have been used in Traditional Chinese Medicine and other Eastern traditions for their value beyond basic nutrition. Only recently have they become widely known in the West.

Many of them are simply edible mushrooms, and in the EU they are sold as food. You may even know some of them from your local market: Shiitake, Oyster mushroom, Maitake and Lion's Mane. Others, like Reishi and Chaga, are traditionally prepared as teas or extracts. And the fungal world has given modern medicine one of its greatest gifts: penicillin, the first antibiotic, was discovered in a mould.

Medicinal mushrooms such as Lion's Mane, Reishi and Shiitake

What defines a medicinal mushroom?

Medicinal mushrooms are mushrooms with a long tradition of use for wellbeing and a rich content of bioactive compounds that scientists are studying with great interest. Unlike psychedelic mushrooms, they do not change your state of consciousness.

Key bioactive compounds

Beta-glucans are polysaccharides found in the cell walls of mushrooms. They are among the most studied mushroom compounds, especially for their interaction with the immune system. Research is promising, but most studies are early or in the lab, so there are no approved health claims for mushroom beta-glucans in the EU.

Triterpenoids are found in mushrooms like Reishi and Chaga and are being studied for their antioxidant properties. Again, this research is still developing.

Each mushroom also has its own story. Lion's Mane is traditionally known as a mushroom for the mind. Chaga, which grows on birch trees in cold northern forests, has long been brewed as a tea in Siberia and Scandinavia. Read more about Lion's Mane and Chaga.

Extracts or whole mushrooms?

Some medicinal mushrooms, like Shiitake, are delicious to cook with. Others, like Reishi, Chaga and Lion's Mane, are usually taken as extracts. Mushroom cell walls are made of chitin, which our bodies cannot easily break down, so hot water or dual extraction helps release the compounds. The ratio on a label, for example 15:1, tells you how many kilos of mushroom were used to make 1 kilo of extract. That is why a good extract is far more concentrated than plain mushroom powder.

A good extract tells you exactly what you get: the part of the mushroom used, the extraction method and the beta-glucan content.

Psychedelic mushrooms

Psychedelic mushrooms growing in nature

What defines a psychedelic mushroom?

Psychedelic mushrooms, often called magic mushrooms, contain psilocybin, a naturally occurring psychoactive compound found in more than 200 mushroom species around the world. In the body, psilocybin is converted into psilocin, which acts on serotonin receptors in the brain. This can lead to vivid sensory experiences, altered perceptions and profound shifts in consciousness.

Spiritual and cultural significance

Psychedelic mushrooms have a long history of sacred use. In Mesoamerica, the Aztecs called them teonánacatl, often translated as flesh of the gods, and Mazatec healers in Oaxaca, Mexico, still work with them in healing ceremonies called veladas. For these cultures, the mushrooms were teachers and doorways to the divine.

Legal and medical considerations

Despite this long spiritual history, psilocybin is a controlled substance under the 1971 UN Convention on Psychotropic Substances and is illegal in most countries. Its legal status is changing in a few places: since 2023, Australia allows authorised psychiatrists to prescribe it for some patients, and the US state of Oregon allows supervised psilocybin services.

At the same time, clinical research is exploring psilocybin-assisted therapy, especially for depression, always in a controlled setting with professional guidance. The results are promising, but this is a field for researchers and qualified therapists, not for self-experimentation. Herbal Cacao does not sell psychedelic mushrooms.

Medicinal mushrooms nourish. Psychedelic mushrooms alter consciousness. They are two very different worlds within the same magical kingdom.

The magic of fungi

If you feel drawn to the world of mushrooms, I warmly recommend the documentary Fantastic Fungi (2019). It explores the magical, medicinal and ecological roles of fungi, from the underground networks that connect trees to their role in recycling life on Earth. It is a beautiful reminder of how much we still have to learn from this hidden kingdom.

Combining medicinal mushrooms with cacao

Medicinal mushrooms and ceremonial cacao are a beautiful pairing. The rich, earthy taste of mushrooms blends naturally with cacao, and both have been honoured in ritual for centuries. A simple way to begin:

  1. Warm 20 g of ceremonial cacao slowly with water or plant milk (recommended temperature 75 to 80°C).
  2. Add your mushroom extract, or choose a blend where it is already added.
  3. Whisk until frothy, set an intention and sip slowly.

For meditation you can use 20 g of cacao, and for a ceremony 30 g or more, never more than 50 g. If you take medication, are pregnant or breastfeeding, please check with your doctor before using medicinal mushrooms.

Free Herbal Cacao e-book, beginner's guide to ceremonial cacao

At Herbal Cacao, we have done this for you in our mushroom blends. Golden Focus combines cacao from Alta Verapaz with Lion's Mane, a 15:1 dual extract with more than 20% beta-glucans, plus cardamom, cinnamon and vanilla. It was awarded 3 stars at the Nourish Awards 2026. Divine Strength combines cacao with Chaga.

Curious to taste cacao and medicinal mushrooms together? Discover Golden Focus

Herbal Cacao Golden Focus, ceremonial cacao with Lion's Mane

With love, Sharon, founder of Herbal Cacao

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between medicinal and psychedelic mushrooms?
Medicinal mushrooms, like Lion's Mane, Reishi and Chaga, are not psychoactive and have a long tradition of use for wellbeing. Psychedelic mushrooms contain psilocybin, which alters consciousness and is illegal in most countries.

Will medicinal mushrooms make me high?
No. Medicinal mushrooms do not contain psilocybin and do not change your state of consciousness.

Why are medicinal mushrooms often taken as extracts?
Mushroom cell walls are made of chitin, which our bodies cannot easily break down. Extraction with hot water, or hot water and alcohol, releases the compounds and concentrates them.

Can I mix medicinal mushrooms with ceremonial cacao?
Yes, they blend beautifully. You can add an extract to your cacao or choose a ready-made blend like Golden Focus with Lion's Mane.

Sources and further reading

  • Wasser, S. P. (2014). Medicinal mushroom science: current perspectives, advances, evidences, and challenges. Biomedical Journal, 37(6), 345 to 356.
  • Fleming, A. (1929). On the antibacterial action of cultures of a Penicillium. British Journal of Experimental Pathology, 10(3), 226 to 236.
  • United Nations (1971). Convention on Psychotropic Substances.
  • Carhart-Harris, R. et al. (2021). Trial of psilocybin versus escitalopram for depression. New England Journal of Medicine, 384, 1402 to 1411.
  • Schwartzberg, L. (director) (2019). Fantastic Fungi. Moving Art.

← Older Post Newer Post →